Income Streams in Retirement: Why There’s No One-Size-Fits-All Answer

Over the past several weeks, a familiar set of questions has come up in client meetings at Mason. When should Social Security start? How do required minimum distributions fit in? What should happen to an old 401(k)? How much can be withdrawn each year? What about a pension?

These questions tend to arrive together because they are really one question:

“How do the pieces of retirement income planning fit together?”

Each source of income affects the others, which is why no single formula applies to every household. This post outlines the main variables Mason Wealth Advisors walk through with clients, so you know what to consider before sitting down with an advisor.

When Should You Claim Social Security?

Social Security timing is rarely a standalone decision. It is one piece of a larger income puzzle, and the variables that shape it often have as much to do with the rest of a household’s finances as with the benefit itself.

Common factors include:

Health and family longevity. The decision involves a trade-off between receiving a lower benefit for more years or  receiving a larger benefit that starts later for a few less years.

Income needs and other resources. Delaying from age 62 to 70 can mean going without Social Security income for up to eight years. Whether that is realistic depends on whether savings, a pension, or continued working income can bridge the gap.

Employment. Anyone who claims before full retirement age (FRA) while still working is subject to the earnings test. Benefits withheld under the test are not permanently lost, since they are added back into the benefit calculation after FRA.

Taxes. Depending on a household’s overall income, up to 85% of a Social Security benefit may be subject to federal income tax. Withdrawals from other accounts, including RMDs, count toward that income, so they can affect how much of the benefit is taxed. No more than 85% of a benefit is ever taxable, and higher-income households may reach that level regardless of how other decisions are sequenced.

Possible changes. Some households factor in potential changes to the Social Security system, the tax code, or a move to a state with different income rates or taxation of social security.

Personal perspective. Households also differ on what size of difference between claiming early and later is meaningful to them.

How Does Claiming Age Affect a Spouse’s Benefits?

For married couples, the claiming decision affects two people. If only one spouse worked, the non-earning spouse may be eligible for a spousal benefit of up to 50% of the primary worker’s benefit at the worker’s own FRA. That amount is based on the worker’s benefit at FRA, not on what the worker claims. Delayed retirement credits increase the worker’s own benefit but do not increase the spousal add-on. The worker must also have filed before the spouse can collect on that record, and a spouse who claims before their own FRA receives a permanently reduced amount.

If both spouses worked but earned different amounts over their careers, a different set of considerations comes into play, which is also dependent on the ages of each spouse.

And survivor benefits work differently. When one spouse passes away, the survivor generally receives the full benefit the deceased spouse was receiving, including any delayed retirement credits. This is one reason couples often consider the higher earner’s claiming age as a decision that affects the surviving spouse, not only the household during both lifetimes.

What Are Required Minimum Distributions, and How Do They Affect Other Income?

Required minimum distributions (RMDs) are the minimum amounts the IRS requires account owners to withdraw each year from tax-deferred retirement accounts once they reach a certain age. The amount is based on the account balance as of December 31 of the prior year and an age-based factor from the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table.

Under current law, RMDs generally begin at age 73 for those born between 1951 and 1959, and at age 75 for those born in 1960 or later. A first RMD can be delayed until April 1 of the following year but doing so means taking two RMDs in the same calendar year. Inherited IRAs follow their own set of rules.

RMDs are generally taxed as ordinary income, although an IRA funded in part with after-tax contributions may have some basis that reduces the taxable portion. Because they are added to income, RMDs can create a “stacking” effect:

  • They count toward how much of a Social Security benefit is taxable.
  • They count toward modified adjusted gross income, which can affect Medicare premiums through the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA).
  • They are required whether or not the money is needed for spending.

Some households respond by planning ahead. Drawing down tax-deferred accounts or completing partial Roth conversions in the years before RMDs begin can smooth taxable income over time, though it means paying tax earlier than required, which carries its own opportunity cost. For some households, particularly those who expect to remain in higher tax brackets throughout retirement, these strategies may offer limited benefit. This is one more reason the analysis is specific to each family.

Account owners over age 70½ who give to charity may also consider a Qualified Charitable Distribution (QCD), which sends funds directly from an IRA to a charity and excludes that amount from taxable income. QCDs are subject to annual limits that adjust over time.

How Does a Systematic Withdrawal Strategy Work?

A systematic withdrawal strategy is a predefined set of rules for how much to withdraw from a portfolio each year. The goal is to balance present lifestyle against the risk of running short later, and there is no fixed percentage that suits everyone. The right approach depends on several variables:

Account types. Taxable, tax-deferred, and Roth accounts are taxed differently, so the order of withdrawals matters. A common starting point is to draw from taxable accounts first, then tax-deferred accounts, then Roth accounts, but any such ordering needs to be personalized for the household.

Investment allocation. In any given year, a household may be selling equities, fixed income, or a combination, depending on market conditions and goals.

Liquidity. Illiquid assets cannot be tapped flexibly.

Guaranteed income. Social Security, pensions, and annuities can reduce how much needs to come from the portfolio.

Flexibility and risk tolerance. A household that can absorb spending cuts may choose a different approach than one that cannot. Each approach balances the trade-offs between having to cut spending, running short of money, and leaving more behind than intended.

Goals. How much a household wants to spend and how much it wants to leave to heirs shape the withdrawal rate.

What Is Sequence of Returns Risk?

Sequence of returns risk is the risk that poor market returns early in retirement, while withdrawals are being made, can deplete a portfolio faster than average returns would suggest. Selling investments to fund living expenses during a downturn means a larger share of holdings is sold at lower prices, leaving less invested to participate in any later recovery. This is one reason the first years of retirement receive particular attention in withdrawal planning.

What Are the Options for an Old 401(k)?

When leaving an employer, a 401(k) generally offers three paths: keep the account where it is, roll it into a new employer’s plan, or roll it into a rollover IRA. Each involves trade-offs:

Investment options and fees. Plans and IRAs differ in the investments available and in plan or management costs.

The Rule of 55. The IRS allows penalty-free withdrawals from a workplace plan for those who leave their job during or after the calendar year they turn 55. If the funds are rolled to an IRA, distributions before age 59½ may be subject to the early withdrawal penalty.

Backdoor Roth contributions. Keeping pre-tax money in a 401(k) rather than a rollover IRA can help avoid the pro rata rule, which affects how backdoor Roth contributions are taxed.

Creditor protection. 401(k) plans may offer stronger creditor protection under ERISA or certain state laws than IRAs.

RMD mechanics. RMDs must be calculated and taken separately from each 401(k) plan, while balances in multiple IRAs can be aggregated for the calculation.

Consolidation. Combining accounts can simplify oversight and withdrawal planning.

How Does a Pension Fit Into Retirement Income Planning?

Pensions are less common than they once were. As 401(k) plans became widespread after the early 1980s, many employers shifted from defined-benefit pensions to defined-contribution plans, which moved investment and market risk from the employer to the employee. Longer lifespans, interest rate changes, and more frequent job changes also contributed to the shift. For households that do have a pension, it remains a significant variable.

A pension can provide lifetime income, with the employer managing the investments. Key decisions include:

Survivor options. Many pensions offer payout options based on a single life, joint lives with a spouse, or a guaranteed term of payments.

Timing. Starting a pension early generally means a permanently reduced benefit, while waiting until full retirement age or later results in a higher monthly amount. Which approach produces a greater lifetime total depends on how long benefits are received.

Interaction with the rest of the plan. Delaying a pension may require larger portfolio withdrawals in early retirement, which can also create room for Roth conversions in some situations. Starting early can ease pressure on investment accounts.

Lump sum or monthly payments. Some pensions allow a lump sum rollover to an IRA, which then follows the same decision points as other IRA withdrawals. Current interest rates at the decision point can also impact this consideration of lump sum or monthly payments.

Why Does Retirement Income Planning Require a Coordinated Plan?

Each of these topics affects the others. The age at which Social Security begins influences how much needs to come from savings. Withdrawals from savings affect RMDs, taxes, and Medicare premiums. A pension election changes how much risk a portfolio needs to carry. None of these decisions happens in isolation, and each household’s puzzle looks different.

An advisor can help sort through the variables specific to a family and coordinate the sequence of decisions over time, including adjusting the plan as factors change and evolve. If these questions sound familiar, a conversation with a Mason advisor is a reasonable place to start.

Frequently Asked Questions About Retirement Income Planning

What determines the right age to claim Social Security?

There is no single right age. Health and life expectancy, income needs, spousal strategy, and employment plans all play a role. Claiming before full retirement age while still working can trigger the earnings test, so work plans are part of the decision.

How does claiming early or waiting affect a spouse’s benefits?

A spouse may receive up to 50% of the worker’s benefit at the worker’s full retirement age, and that amount does not grow if the worker delays. A surviving spouse generally receives the benefit the deceased was receiving, including delayed retirement credits, so the higher earner’s claiming age can affect the survivor.

What are RMDs and when do they generally begin?

Required minimum distributions are annual minimum withdrawals from tax-deferred retirement accounts. They generally begin at age 73 for those born from 1951 to 1959 and at age 75 for those born in 1960 or later. The first RMD can be delayed until April 1 of the following year, which results in two RMDs in that calendar year.

How do RMDs interact with other retirement income sources?

RMDs are generally taxed as ordinary income and can increase how much of a Social Security benefit is taxable. They also count toward income used to set Medicare IRMAA premiums. Planning ahead, such as with partial Roth conversions or Qualified Charitable Distributions, may help manage the effect for some households.

How do people generally decide how much to withdraw each year?

Most approaches aim to balance current lifestyle against longevity risk. Spending needs, legacy goals, account types, guaranteed income sources, and flexibility all shape the withdrawal rate, which is why it is personalized rather than fixed.

What is sequence of returns risk and why does it matter early in retirement?

It is the risk that poor market returns early in retirement, combined with ongoing withdrawals, can deplete a portfolio faster than average returns would suggest. Selling during a downturn means selling more shares to meet the same spending need, leaving less invested for any recovery.

What are the general options for an old 401(k)?

The three general options are to keep the account with the former employer’s plan, roll it into a new employer’s plan, or roll it into a rollover IRA. Each differs in investment choices, fees, withdrawal rules, and creditor protection.

What should someone weigh when deciding whether to roll a 401(k) into an IRA or a new employer plan?

Common considerations include fees and expenses, investment options, early withdrawal rules such as the Rule of 55, creditor protection, and the effect on backdoor Roth IRA contributions.

What is the general trade-off between a pension lump sum and monthly annuity payments?

A monthly annuity provides predictable income with no investment management, but may be exposed to inflation and offers limited legacy options beyond survivor benefits. A lump sum rolled to an IRA offers control, flexibility, and the ability to leave unspent funds to heirs, but places market and longevity risk on the household. Interest rates at the time of retirement also affect the lump sum and annuity amounts.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or investment advice. Mason is a fee-based advisory firm. Please consult with a qualified attorney, tax professional, or financial advisor regarding your specific situation.

David Gilbert, CFP®, J.D., Managing Director at Mason Investment Advisory Services, which he joined in July 2001, earning his CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ certification that same year. He began his career as a corporate attorney in San Francisco, focusing on securities transactions, before moving into corporate development and later wealth management. He holds a Juris Doctor from the University of Virginia and a Bachelor of Arts in U.S. History from Princeton University.

Blaine Homan, CFP®, is a Wealth Advisor at Mason Investment Advisory Services. He earned his CFP® certification in 2021 and holds a B.S. in Finance from Virginia Tech’s Pamplin College of Business. Prior to joining Mason, he gained client service and financial planning experience at Centurion Wealth Management.